So, those ridiculously coy posting memes on Facebook about purse or bra color that are supposedly for raising awareness about breast cancer? You know, the ones that DON'T ACTUALLY MENTION CANCER? Yeah, people more articulate than I (like, oh, [livejournal.com profile] cleolinda) have posted very good rants about the idiocy of those memes.

However. There's a new one.



Simply type in "I do it (....) (....) and I (....). Message me for details."

Fill in the first blank with where you do your breast-self examinations (for example (in the shower, in the bedroom, before I get dressed).

Fill in the second blank with how often you do your breast self-examinations (for example - every month, almost every day, when I'm on my cycle, etc.).

And finally, fill in the third blank with information about your mammograms (for example, I started when I was 40, I did it for the first time this year, or I haven't done it yet, but will when the time is right.)

For example - my original post looked like this:
"I do it in the shower, at least once a month, and I did it for the first time this year. PM/message me for details."



"Hopefully this will raise awareness not only of Breast Cancer, but also of the practices that can help detect it early and prevent it from being a killer."

How, exactly, will these sorts of posts raise awareness of breast cancer and detection practices when they're just more coy, tee-hee nonsense?

You want to raise awareness about breast cancer? Then talk about it. Openly. Don't hide behind coy and giggly innuendo. TALK ABOUT IT. Talk about how it has affected your life. Talk about how stupid it is to put off scheduling mammograms. (Hi, I'm an idiot. I'm very lucky that the check-up I recently had was fine, and ignoring the reminders to schedule that appointment was REALLY DUMB OF ME. Don't use me as a role model for this sort of thing.)

My apologies to the handful of you who have included me on FB messages suggesting women make these sorts of posts. I know you mean well. But this sort of, well, pointless internet "activism" make me crazy.

From: [identity profile] rimrunner.livejournal.com


I've been doing my bit to counter teh stupid by making posts of actual substance on the topic. Being coy about it salts my cocoa for a whole host of reasons.

From: [identity profile] junya.livejournal.com


Promise me, when we're old, you'll come sit next to me in a rocking chair on a porch with a shotgun.

From: [identity profile] master-cobweb.livejournal.com


I TOTALLY agree! I had a rant about this on my Facebook status as well. I hate the "pinkification", women only kind of attitude of these games as well. Men are not only capable of getting breast cancer (though it's very rare) but they are fathers, brothers, sons, friends, etc. of women who can get or have already gotten breast cancer and they deserve the chance to show their support as well. The whole snickering, "keeping men wondering for days" games going around Facebook are so immature, off-topic, and excluding of a huge group of potential supporters of the cause of Breast Cancer Awareness. As you say, why not just come out and say "It's Breast Cancer Awareness Month" rather than some lame innuendo?

From: [identity profile] dporowski.livejournal.com


Wondering? I'm not wondering. I KNOW they're morons. What's to wonder?

From: [identity profile] recalcitrant-lj.livejournal.com


These annoy the shit out of me.

A high school acquaintance, who has me friends on FB, recently put up one that was something like "Turn your FB page camo for the day to support our troops".

How the hell does a camo page support anything, exactly?

From: [identity profile] bork.livejournal.com


Thank you.

I have similar thoughts about a couple of other issues, but nothing coherent enough to put in my LJ.

From: [identity profile] martygreene.livejournal.com


There's a reason I was digging for Heather's ranty-post about the whole awareness marketing thing.

I wish I could afford to get mammograms done, and that when I had insurance that they'd have covered it. Yes, I'm young- but estrogen based cancers run so heavily and young in my family it's almost a matter of WHEN not IF.

From: [identity profile] brockulfsen.livejournal.com


Facebook is a sort of sugar coated retreat to childhood, reduced to a mythical pre-PG13 coyness where nobody has boobies and no-one wants to see them.

If it were not the only way to reach a large number of the people I know, I wouldn't bother. (Although while I'm there I do play Mafia Wars)

From: [identity profile] falconwhitaker.livejournal.com


There's also one going around where, apparently, posting the location where you leave your handbag will magically make people know more about cancer. It's ridiculous and it doesn't do anything! Why don't the people posting these statuses volunteer at a cancer charity shop or raise some money or just make a flipping donation instead of being coy and silly? Like you said, they mean well, but they don't accomplish anything :(

From: [identity profile] princess-lilam.livejournal.com


I also REFUSE to take part in this stupid game on facebook. It does nothing to raise awareness and only makes you look cheap by "ooh I like it on the kitchen counter"
The other one is just...I am speechless at the tackiness of it all.

From: [identity profile] savannarama.livejournal.com


I'm glad to have missed this.

I'm wondering if the cheaper vintners have released their pink-ribboned bottles of wine yet, however. Alcohol consumption is a risk factor in breast cancer, but not like you'd know it when you see those bottles. They ought to be ashamed.

From: [identity profile] rimrunner.livejournal.com


A friend of mine hipped me to http://thinkbeforeyoupink.org/, which is awesome.

From: [identity profile] mahariel.livejournal.com


This, except not just the wine, but a huge number of products geared towards women, especially cosmetics and body care products.

Instead of slapping a pink ribbon on and donating some miniscule percentage of your profits, how about developing products without the substances that have been linked to breast cancer? Oh, wait, that'd make sense and be responsible....

From: [identity profile] zmayhem.livejournal.com


Bless you. I'll have to go seek out Cleolinda's rant as well, but yours does the job just fine.

We had a breast cancer walkathon through our neighborhood last Sunday, and while I'm all for snark and humor and joy in the face of grimness and death, something in me died just a little when I saw one pink-tutu-and-fairy-wing'd contingent march past with its leader proudly holding aloft a plushie boob on a stick, surrounded by an aureole of pink felt lightning bolts. Something died, and then came roaring back to coldly furious life when I went to the car and found that one of the walkers had stuck a business card on the windshield of every car on the block that read, "Save the ta-tas! Come to my website to sponsor my walk against breast cancer and show your ta-ta love."

Oh my feminist heart, it hurts, and my feminist tongue, it is tied up and incoherent with rage.

From: [identity profile] nekusagi.livejournal.com


The other thing is that breast self-exams really do more harm than good- they don't do anything to stop the cancer itself from developing and can lead to unnecessary biopsies.

But yeah, I hate this innuendo stuff. TYSM for this post.

From: [identity profile] sketchbookexile.livejournal.com


It really irritates me with all of the pink and breast cancer awareness things that do not do a damn thing to really talk about the awareness and education most people need. Speaking as a woman with multiple tumors in my breast with a high risk for the disease I get enraged with all of the imagery that does NOT educate women at all. My rage only gets worse at the middle school I teach since we have a group called "pretty in pink" that don't do a damn thing to educate our kids about the disease really.

From: [identity profile] ladyraven13.livejournal.com


word.

It's been annoying me for days, it's about as bad as all the game apps...I really don't care if so-and-so needs my help to complete their demon wings or so-and-so found a treasure chest and wants to share. ugh.

From: [identity profile] theblackdeer.livejournal.com


I had not seen this one yet. It makes my head splodey.

From: [identity profile] usagi-moon.livejournal.com


omg I hate those stupid things popping up in my inbox, and then when someone I don't know responds to it, my mailbox fills up with crap from people I don't know it, it is so frustreating.

Breast cancer = I eat Yoplait! lick the lids, send them. the end.

And more if I need to. :) but yeah, I don't get why people just don't talk about it openly either.

From: [identity profile] mahariel.livejournal.com


Don't get me started on the "save the boobies!" campaign.

From: [identity profile] sound0fwings.livejournal.com


I'm totally with you on this. The FB stuff is stupid. Which is part of the reason I don't have a FB anymore. Does it make it a little harder to keep up with people? A little. But I don't need to know every time my sister's cat does something cute and bigger things will eventually reach me. [shrug]

The sad thing is there are so many ways for people to get involved that are more... productive. I stumbled across one this morning and you know... it took me less than five minutes to read the info and make a donation. But really, why spend five minutes doing something helpful when you can tee-hee about goofy comments on FB? =( http://community.livejournal.com/steamfashion/2844302.html
ext_26950: (Joker headdesk)

From: [identity profile] tonks07.livejournal.com


Wow... I hadn't heard about this. I knew about the 'where you leave your handbag' posting and thought that was pointless but this is even more so! I thought the first year with the bra colors was cute but now it's getting ridiculous! You're right, people should just be more open about subjects like this. Coy facebook statuses just confuse me.

From: [identity profile] ouranophobe.livejournal.com


Well, you know me, my darling... it's not the tech that annoys me... it's the vapid idiots who think this sort of giggly crap is going to have an impact. Twitter, FB, Livejournal, chain emails, chain letters sent by regular post are just a progression of facilitators to "slacktivism". Apparently, it's easier to spam a load of crap via various media than it is to open up one's wallet and give a fiver toward the cause, and original thought is haaaaaaaaaaard! </whinge>

... not that I'm, y'know, annoyed by this stuff, or anything...

From: [identity profile] sistawendy.livejournal.com


I do wonder on what planet that sort of thing would do any good at all. Wherever it is, I don't want to go.

Long time no type, by the way!

From: [identity profile] sistawendy.livejournal.com


Nibs just asked me if it's time for my first mammogram. Time to email Doc.

From: [identity profile] malicecarnivora.livejournal.com


I've seen this. I've also seen a slew of pink-washed profile pictures that I had NO IDEA had to do with breast cancer awareness until someone mentioned it in their status.

You know what I put in my Facebook status?
"Someone you know will be affected by breast cancer. Someone you know will die from it, will have a loved one die from it, will have to have a mastectomy. Do something to help. Keep your pink pictures and ribbons and all the other pink shit; I want knowledge. I want action." And included a link to the National Breast Cancer Foundation (nationalbreastcancer.org (http://www.nationalbreastcancer.org))

Cancer isn't cute. It isn't fun. It's not some stupid internet meme. And it's definitely not sexy and flirty.

From: [identity profile] tzuki17.livejournal.com


well, although 'fluffy pink activism' isn't my cup of tea, I'd have to say 'there are horses for courses'. Here, similar-minded folk may take a contrary position & thats fine, but for every woman who reads political philosophy or poetry, there are 100 more who don't and without meaning to sound patronising (whilst being well aware I am) its important to speak & explain in ways that appeal to a huge variety of hearts & minds.

I am ranting & idealistic by nature, but now, in my approaching dotage, I am far less judgemental. I wouldn't want to go for a walk in my bra, but i'll happily give money to someone who wants to; I've written that cryptic message about the colour of my underwear & I've given support to family members & friends who have suffered or survived (& sadly sometimes lost) cancer...I never felt anything i did (no matter how trite it might be) cheapened the actuality of the disease.

when you have held someone as they died, it doesn't necesarily make you angry that someone dresses in a pink tutu because they believe they are helping. When you know your own time is more finite than originally expected, it doesn't automatically follow you'll want more harsh reality.

you might, you might not...vive la differernce,I say; if its not your cup of tea just don't do it, but please please don't judge well-meaning folk who think they are helping (& sometimes you know, they actually are)
matt1993: (qun)

From: [personal profile] matt1993


I've never seen these Facebook memes (not the breast cancer ones, anyway; I saw the camo one that recalcitrant_lj mentioned), but at school, some of my (female, mind you) classmates wore bracelets that say "I ♥ Boobies! (keep a breast)".
.

Most Popular Tags

Powered by Dreamwidth Studios

Style Credit

Expand Cut Tags

No cut tags